Issue tracking: Where business and technology clash

Earlier I wrote about security being a topic where business and technology clash. Here's another one: issue tracking.

Issue tracking: two words with a very wide definition. It's tracking issues found by development: Those things that you still need to improve or those bugs that you found yourself and still need to fix. Or even your TODO list, depending on your way of working. Then there's the issues that testing finds in your products. And last but not least: the issues that clients find in the software, either during the testing of one of your iteration results or even when the system is already in production. And especially in that last category, we find the first clash. Development (and testing also in some companies) need a system where they can register issues, track them, close them, keep track of which version/build is the affected version and in which version/build the issue was fixed, and if possible with integration with the version management system of choice (Subversion in our case). This is vital information for development. Then there's the business. For the business, in particular account management and sales, it is very important to know what is happening for any given client. When a client calls, or when they go to visit a client, they need to have a clear view on what topics might come up or which topics really need to be discussed. So, in a perfect world, there would be this central system that can do all these things. Unfortunately, especially in the open source world, there is no such things. At my current employer, we use SugarCRM for customer relationship management. For most projects, the from a technical point of view completely inadequate bug report system of this CRM is used. For our biggest project, which is probably also the one we're currently handling in the most professional way, we use trac including the Subversion hooks. This works perfectly for me as a developer, but is giving account management and sales headaches. So again, clashes may occur. In a perfect world, there would be one integrated system. Due to our Open Source philosophy, we prefer to stay away from the big commercial packages. Does anyone know of a good solution, aside from developing our own SugarCRM plugin or writing a full custom piece of software to handle everything?
Add comment

Comments

gravatar Joe Ponczak: Great post. You can take a look at Lighthouse – www.artifactsoftware.com – it offers issue, defect, change requests, requirements management, task management, timesheets and test management for free.

We will be providing API and IDE integration soon as well.

For full disclosure, I am Artifact’s Product Director.


June 15, 2007
gravatar Alex: There’s also FogBugz- It’s not free (I think they charge per-developer), but licenses come with the source code- so you’re free to modify it in any fashion you want, add plugins on the fly, etc. A company I used to work for migrated from Trac to Fogbugz, and it was a huge improvement to our workflow. Not that Trac isn’t awesome in it’s own right- It just fulfills a slightly narrower set of needs.


June 15, 2007
gravatar Andries Seutens: Hi Stefan! At work I use the Mantis bugtracker… however this tool doesnt have subversion hooks, but it seems to work pretty well, and it’s easy understandable for clients as well.


July 12, 2007

Php5_zce_logo

Upcoming events

I will be speaking 17-02-2012: Techademy Trainingday February
I will be speaking 23-02-2012: Zend Webinar: Git for Subversion Users

Tags

1337 2008 2010 2011 4developers access modifiers accessibility AdaLovelaceDay09 advent agavi agile alfred amsterdam apache api apple article articles atk atkMetaNode audioscrobbler automation azure backwards compatibility barcelona barcodes bash bbc bbq beatstad belgium best practices bittorrent blogging blogs boards of canada book books bughuntday bundle caching cake cal evans calendar career cat cerf certificate cfp clear cms cologne common sense communities community components conference conferences contest continuous integration contribute contribution crisis css custom d-day datetime DbFinderPlugin decorator decorators deployment devdays development directoryindex docblox doctrine documentation download dpc dpc09 dpc10 dpc11 DPC2008 dreamhost drupal dv7 eclipse ed editors efficiency enterprise errors event events expertise ezcomponents facebook finland flickr fork framework frameworks freelance freeze frontend fun game games geoip germany getting real git github gnome-do google google calendar googletalk graceful degradation hack hackers hidden gem hiphop howto hp HR html http i386 ibuildings icann ide ideasofmarch idm imovie indy ingewikkeld integration international php conference internet interview ipad IPC ipc ipc08 ipc10 ipc11se iterm2 javascript jenkins jenkins-php job job openings jobeet john peel joomla joomladays kiva kubuntu launcher launchy left on the web libraries library lighttpd lime linktuesday linux live london loudblog m2ts mac magazines malware mambo marjolein mediterra meeting meme meta methodology micro-financing microframework microsoft migration movie music mysql namespace namespaces netbeans netherlands newsfire nllgg nos odmarco open source opinion ORM osx paradiso paris partnership pavilion pear pecl performance personal pfc10 pfc11 pfcongres pfcongrez pfz photo php php5.3 phpabstract phpazure phpBB phpbb phpbelgium phpbenelux phpbnl10 phpday phpdoc phpdocumentor phpgg phpitalia phpnw phpnw08 phpnw11 phpstorm phptek phptek09 phpuk2009 phpUnderControl phpunit php|architect php|tek podcast politics portability postcrossing presentation presentations private projects protected prototype PSR-0 public python qa qr codes re2c recruiting refactoring review rewrite ruby on rails san francisco schedule scifi script security sensio seven things sfdaycgn sflive2011 shell scripting silex simplexml slides smfony software sogeti solar sound speakers spl ssh standard standards star trek static steer strings stylesheets subversion symfony symfony live Symfony2 symfonycamp symfonyday symfonylive symfonyUnderControlPlugin talk talks techademy technology techportal tek09 telecommuting terratec terrorism testfest testing textmate textpattern the right tool timeout tips tld todo tomas tools training twig uncon unet usability usergroup validation vhost video vim vinyl virus warp webinar weblogging webservices wiki windows winphp women wordpress work workshop world world of warcraft wpi writing wunderlist xml xpath xsd yara year youtube zc11 ZCE zemanta zend zend framework zend server zend studio zendcon Zend_Form zite
© 2004 - 2012 Stefan Koopmanschap + Powered by Symfony, photos powered by Flickr, links powered by Delicious, Shanghai smilies by Iconbuffet. Feeds: rss / atom. Left on the Web v4.4.0.1